Rewilding Europe has become a significant movement aimed at restoring natural landscapes, biodiversity, and balance across the continent. A central aspect of this initiative is the reintroduction of species to areas where they once thrived. However, a unique challenge arises when the species intended for reintroduction is not only extinct in the wild but has been completely wiped from existence. This is the case with the Auroch (Bos primigenius), the ancient ancestor of all modern cattle.
The Auroch: Europe's Ancient Super-Bull
The Auroch was a powerful animal, roaming vast stretches of Europe, Asia, and North Africa for millions of years before its extinction in the 17th century. These animals were depicted in prehistoric cave paintings, admired by historical figures like Julius Caesar, and revered in various mythologies, symbolizing strength and primal power. Their extinction was driven by overhunting, habitat destruction, and diseases spread by domestic cattle. By 1627, the last known Auroch had died in Poland.
Despite their extinction, the Auroch has left a lasting legacy on the human imagination and the landscape itself. Known for their massive size—bulls could weigh up to 1,000 kilograms—and their role in shaping the environment through grazing, Aurochs were once a keystone species in the ecosystems they inhabited. Their grazing behavior helped maintain a mosaic of habitats that supported diverse plant and animal life, from open grasslands to mixed forests.
Before their extinction, aurochs were domesticated, giving rise to modern cattle breeds. The domestication process began around 8,000 to 10,000 years ago in the Near East, leading to the two main types of cattle we see today: Bos taurus (European cattle) and Bos indicus (zebu or humped cattle).
The Concept of Rewilding
Rewilding aims to restore ecosystems to their natural state before significant human interference. It often involves reintroducing native species that can help maintain or restore natural processes. In Europe, this concept has been gaining momentum as a way to combat biodiversity loss and revitalize rural economies through eco-tourism.
Frans Vera, a Dutch biologist, challenged the traditional view that pre-human Europe was predominantly forested. He proposed that the landscape was a dynamic mosaic of forests, grasslands, and wetlands shaped largely by the grazing activities of large herbivores, including the Auroch. This theory, known as "natural grazing," suggests that reintroducing large grazers could help recreate these biodiverse landscapes.
Breeding the Auroch Back to Life
Given the Auroch's extinction, reintroducing them directly isn't possible. Instead, scientists and conservationists have turned to back-breeding, a process that involves selectively breeding domestic cattle that carry genes from their wild ancestors. The goal is to recreate an animal that closely resembles the extinct Auroch in both appearance and ecological function.
“The main idea of the Tauros Programme is to back-breed these animals into becoming a fully self-sufficient, wild-living bovine species, that genetically comes as close as ever possible to the original aurochs.” - Ronald Goderie, Director of the Taurus Foundation
Problematic 20th Century Attempts At Recreating the Auroch
The first attempt to revive the Auroch was made in the 1930s by two German zoo directors, the brothers Lutz and Heinz Heck. The brothers aimed to recreate the extinct aurochs by selectively breeding modern cattle that retained some of the aurochs' genetic traits. This process, known as "breeding back," involved using various cattle breeds, including Spanish fighting bulls, to develop an animal that resembled the aurochs in appearance and behavior.
However, these animals were bred primarily for size and aggression rather than to closely mimic the Auroch's physical characteristics or ecological role. Their aggression has posed issues for some producers.
The Heck brothers' work was part of a broader Nazi interest in promoting Aryan ideals through nature and genetics. The Heck cattle became infamous for their aggressive temperament and were used in Nazi propaganda to symbolize strength and purity. After World War II, many Heck cattle were destroyed, but some survived in European conservation parks. The Heck brothers' efforts are now viewed critically due to not only this aggression, but also their association with Nazi ideology and the ethical issues surrounding their breeding experiments.
In 2009, Derek Gow imported over a dozen Heck cattle, known for their aggressive behavior, to his farm in West Devon. Due to their extreme aggression, Gow had to cull seven of the herd to protect his staff, but he kept six calmer cows. Gow noted that there were no incidents where his herd injured anyone. “Since they have gone it is all peaceful again. Peace reigns supreme,” he said. “Despite these problems, I have no regrets at all. It has been a good thing to do and the history of them is fascinating.” (source)
While Heck cattle are not considered true Aurochs, they have been used successfully in some rewilding projects, such as the Oostvaardersplassen nature reserve in the Netherlands, where they contribute to landscape management by grazing.
Contemporary Programs Seeking to Recreate the Auroch
Today, there are several ongoing projects across Europe to create a closer approximation of the Auroch. The Tauros Programme, led by the Taurus Foundation in collaboration with Rewilding Europe, is one of the most ambitious efforts. This project uses genetic analysis and selective breeding of ancient cattle breeds found in Spain, Portugal, Italy, and the Balkans, which are believed to carry significant Auroch genetics.
According to Goderie, it is expected to take about seven generations of selective breeding to achieve a true Auroch-like animal, and the team expects to see results in 2025. The project took only a few generations to demonstrate promising results in both physical characteristics and behaviors reminiscent of the extinct species.
Breeds Initially Chosen for the Tauros Programme
The Tauros Programme employs a strategic breeding approach to recreate a functional equivalent of the extinct aurochs, focusing on genetic diversity, phenotypic traits, behavioral characteristics, and adaptive capacity. By incorporating multiple cattle breeds, the programme ensures a broad genetic base, reducing the risk of inbreeding and enhancing the overall health and resilience of the Tauros herds. The selection process emphasizes cattle that exhibit physical traits similar to the aurochs, such as size, horn shape, coat color, and muscular build. Additionally, natural grazing behavior, strong herd instincts, and adaptability to wild environments are prioritized, as these traits are essential for the ecological role the Tauros are expected to fulfill. The chosen breeds also demonstrate the ability to thrive across various European climates and landscapes, from the wetlands of the Netherlands to the mountainous regions of Croatia and Bulgaria, ensuring their success in diverse rewilding projects.
Sayaguesa
Origin: Indigenous to the Sayago region in northwestern Spain.
Characteristics: Known for their agility, hardiness, and ability to thrive in rugged terrains. Sayaguesa cattle have a strong survival instinct, minimal human intervention needs, and maintain a natural grazing behavior similar to wild aurochs.
Contribution: Their robust constitution and natural behaviors make them ideal candidates for developing a breed capable of managing and shaping diverse European landscapes.
Chianina
Origin: One of the oldest cattle breeds, originating from the Valdichiana area of Tuscany and Emilia-Romagna in Italy.
Characteristics: Renowned for their large size, muscular build, and distinctive white coat with colored heads. Chianina cattle are gentle yet strong, making them suitable for selective breeding.
Contribution: Their impressive size and strength contribute to the physical attributes desired in the recreated aurochs, ensuring the new breed can perform ecological roles effectively.
Pajuna
Origin: Native to the Alentejo region in southern Portugal.
Characteristics: A primitive breed with minimal selective breeding, Pajuna cattle retain many wild traits, including foraging skills, adaptability to harsh climates, and a strong herd instinct.
Contribution: Their genetic diversity and resilience are crucial for increasing the overall genetic variability within the Tauros herds, enhancing the adaptability of the back-bred aurochs.
Maremmana
Origin: Originates from the Tuscany region in Italy.
Characteristics: A hardy breed traditionally used for draught work, Maremmana Pisana cattle are known for their endurance, ability to navigate mountainous terrains, and robust physique.
Contribution: Their physical strength and adaptability to varied environments help in developing a breed capable of surviving and shaping diverse European ecosystems.
Gelbvieh
Origin: Originates from Bavaria in southern Germany.
Characteristics: Known for their high fertility, excellent mothering abilities, and adaptability to different environments. Gelbvieh cattle have a calm temperament and good foraging skills.
Contribution: Their reproductive efficiency and adaptability enhance the genetic pool of the Tauros Programme, facilitating the rapid establishment of sustainable herds.
Highland
Origin: Native to Scotland.
Characteristics: Highland cattle are a Scottish breed, easily recognizable by their long horns and thick, woolly coats. They are extremely hardy and can survive in harsh climates.
Contribution: While not directly contributing to the physical appearance of the aurochs, Highland cattle add genetic diversity and bring traits of hardiness and adaptability, important for free-ranging cattle in various rewilding environments.
Pindos
Origin: Native to the Pindus mountain range in Greece.
Characteristics: A robust and agile breed adapted to mountainous terrains, Pindos cattle possess strong herd instincts and are highly resilient to harsh climatic conditions.
Contribution: Their adaptability and natural behaviors support the development of a breed that can thrive in varied European landscapes, from plains to mountainous regions.
Conflicting Data on Closest Modern-Day Relations to the Auroch
Previous genetic studies have provided some insights into the relationship between European aurochs and modern cattle, but key questions remain, such as the extent of gene flow from aurochs into early domestic cattle and which genes were influenced by domestication. To explore these questions, Dr. David MacHugh of University College Dublin, Ireland, and his team analyzed the complete genome of a 6,750-year-old wild Auroch from Derbyshire, England, and compared it to the genomes of 81 modern cattle and over 1,200 DNA markers from modern cows.
“Our results show the ancestors of modern British and Irish breeds share more genetic similarities with this ancient specimen than other European cattle. This suggests that early British farmers may have restocked their domesticated herds with wild aurochs.” (Dr. MacHugh)
Their findings revealed clear evidence of interbreeding between wild British aurochs and early domesticated cattle, particularly in British and Irish breeds, suggesting that early farmers may have incorporated wild aurochs into their herds. The study also identified genes related to behavior and muscle development as key factors in cattle domestication. These results challenge earlier, simpler models of cattle domestication, showing a more complex process of crossbreeding and gene flow between wild and domesticated cattle as early farmers expanded into new areas like Britain during the Neolithic period.
The Ecological Role and Potential Impact of the Auroch
The reintroduction of Auroch-like cattle to European landscapes is seen as a crucial step in rewilding efforts. Large herbivores like the Auroch are natural ecosystem engineers; their grazing and trampling behaviors create open spaces, prevent forests from becoming too dense, and promote a variety of plant and animal species that depend on open or semi-open habitats.
In regions like the Rhodope Mountains of Bulgaria, reintroduced large herbivores are helping to maintain habitats essential for reptiles, birds, and insects. The presence of these animals prevents the landscape from becoming either completely forested or barren due to overgrazing by domestic livestock. A mosaic landscape of forests, grasslands, and wetlands promotes higher biodiversity and helps support species that are otherwise at risk of losing their habitats.
However, this initiative is not without controversy. Critics argue that recreating extinct species could have unintended ecological consequences, particularly if these new animals behave differently than their ancient counterparts. There are also concerns about the ethical implications of breeding animals specifically to fit human desires for landscape management and aesthetic ideals. Furthermore, the reintroduction of large grazers could potentially require the reintroduction of predators, like wolves, to keep populations in balance, adding another layer of complexity and risk.
The Future of Rewilding and the Auroch
As the Tauros Programme and other similar initiatives progress, the debate over the role of de-extinction and rewilding in conservation continues. Advocates argue that bringing back functional equivalents of extinct species like the Auroch is crucial for restoring Europe's natural heritage and maintaining biodiversity. Critics caution that such projects must be carefully managed to avoid negative impacts on existing ecosystems and species.
Ultimately, the success of these efforts will depend on a combination of scientific research, ethical considerations, and public support. If successful, the reintroduction of Auroch-like cattle could become a model for other rewilding projects around the world, demonstrating the potential benefits of restoring lost species and the ecosystems they once helped to shape.
As Europe continues to grapple with the challenges of biodiversity loss and landscape degradation, the resurrection of the Auroch represents both a bold experiment in conservation and a hopeful step toward a more biodiverse and resilient future.
Kommentare